What STR Operators Get Wrong About Cleaning Turnovers (And How to Fix It)

In the short-term rental (STR) industry, it’s easy to treat cleaning as a checkbox. Guest leaves. Cleaner goes in. Next guest arrives. But ask any experienced operator, and they’ll tell you: turnovers are where things go wrong most often—and where small mistakes create outsized damage.

Lost bookings. Bad reviews. Frustrated guests. Burnt-out vendors. It doesn’t take much.

At TIDY, we've reviewed thousands of turnovers—real jobs, from real teams, across every kind of STR market. And while properties vary, the mistakes tend to repeat themselves. This article breaks down the most common problems we’ve seen, why they happen, and how smart operators are solving them.

Mistake #1: Assuming “Completed” Means “Done Right”

One of the most dangerous assumptions a property manager can make is that because a cleaner marked a job as complete, the unit is truly guest-ready.

In reality, we’ve seen jobs marked “complete” where the toilet was unflushed, the fridge still had a half-empty bottle of soda, or the beds looked made—until you pulled back the cover. The issue isn’t necessarily bad intent. It's a lack of verification.

Verification doesn’t mean micromanaging. But it does mean having a process—photos, checklists, oversight—that closes the feedback loop. We’ve seen operators reduce guest complaints by over 40% simply by requiring timestamped before-and-after photos with every clean.

Mistake #2: Scheduling Cleanings Like It’s 2015

We still see many operators relying on static schedules or manual coordination—texting cleaners directly or assigning jobs days (or weeks) in advance. In theory, it works. In practice, it leads to no-shows, confusion, and overbooked vendors.

The reality is: bookings shift, guests extend, cancellations happen. Turnovers need to be tied to live property data, not static plans. When cleanings are automatically triggered by check-out events—and routed to vendors based on location, capacity, and past performance—the chaos shrinks dramatically.

One mid-size operator we spoke with switched from Google Calendar to an automated turnover system and eliminated almost all last-minute vendor conflicts within one month.

‍

Mistake #3: Thinking “One Checklist Fits All”

It’s common to have a master turnover checklist—wipe counters, vacuum floors, clean mirrors. But STR properties are not hotels. Each unit has quirks, custom instructions, or unique inventory.

What gets missed is often what matters most: the broken lamp switch in Unit 4A. The extra highchair stored in the laundry room. The guest who requested hypoallergenic pillows.

We’ve seen operators reduce negative reviews by simply customizing their turnover checklists per property—and making sure those instructions are actually visible and acknowledged by the vendor.

Mistake #4: Ignoring the Vendor Experience

Cleaning isn’t just a task—it’s a service relationship. And yet, many operators treat their vendors as disposable. Late payments. Incomplete instructions. No real feedback unless something goes wrong.

The result? High vendor churn. Inconsistent performance. Burnout.

Vendors who feel respected and supported are more likely to go the extra mile. That means timely job completion, clearer communication, and more accountability. Smart operators today treat vendors as part of the team—not a temporary fix.

One property manager shared that once she started providing structured feedback and setting up auto-pay through her system, cleaner no-shows dropped by 70%.

Mistake #5: Managing Exceptions by Memory

Most turnover issues aren’t about missing the big picture—they’re about missing the one thing. That one property that needs double-sheeting. The one owner who wants fresh flowers. The one booking with a late checkout.

Without a system to track and flag these exceptions, operators rely on memory or email. And that’s where things slip.

Exception-handling needs to be embedded in your turnover process, not tacked on at the end. The operators who consistently get it right are the ones who build flexibility into the workflow, not chase it afterward.

Getting It Right: What Consistent Turnovers Actually Look Like

In every market, we’ve seen that operational excellence isn't about perfection—it's about repeatability.

The top-performing operators all seem to have a few things in common:

• They verify, rather than assume.
  
  
• They automate, rather than coordinate manually.
  
  
• They customize, instead of using one-size-fits-all.
  
  
• And they create workflows where vendors and managers have shared visibility into what’s happening.
  
  

Cleaning may not be glamorous, but it’s where trust is built—or lost. And in an industry where reputation is everything, clean operations matter more than clean sheets.

Final Thoughts

Turnovers are easy to underestimate—until they cost you. But they’re also one of the most fixable parts of STR operations. With the right structure, tools, and mindset, operators can reduce risk, protect revenue, and deliver better guest experiences without burning themselves (or their teams) out.

‍

Want to see how smarter cleaning management actually works in practice?

‍

👉 Schedule a demo with TIDY and get a closer look at how the most efficient STR teams handle turnovers today.

‍